Are you a compulsive shopper, and how would you know? The psychology of consumer spending can help explain why shopping sometimes stops being a treat and becomes a problem.
Signs of compulsive shopping include thinking about purchases a lot, buying things you do not need, hoping you will feel happier after a shopping trip, feeling a kind of high while buying, and feeling guilty afterwards. If shopping is causing relationship or financial problems but you keep doing it anyway, it may have become compulsive.
In this video, psychotherapist Mark Tyrrell explains how compulsive shopping can be treated.
What Is Emotional Spending?
Emotional spending is buying things to change how you feel rather than because you need them. People often shop to ease stress, boredom, loneliness, or sadness, or to celebrate. The lift is usually brief, and it can be followed by guilt or money worries. Occasional treats are normal; a regular pattern deserves attention.
What the infographic shows about consumer spending
The infographic below, The Psychology of Consumer Spending, gives a brief overview of consumer spending, with a focus on compulsive buying. It covers who tends to overspend, what they buy, whether they pay by cash or card, and how common impulse buying is.
From Illinois Lending
Why compulsive shopping happens
Perhaps the most interesting parts of the infographic are the reasons people shop compulsively and how the brain responds. Psychologists suggest compulsive buying may stem from an emotional gap in someone’s life, sometimes rooted in childhood, from a need for approval or excitement, or simply from difficulty controlling impulses.
Whatever the reason, shopping can feel good. The brain’s reward system responds, dopamine is released, and we feel happy, at least for a while. The trouble starts when someone feels hooked on that feeling and craves more, much as people can with other addictive behaviours. A shopping high is only temporary and cannot meet deeper needs in the long run.
Signs You Are Spending to Soothe a Mood
Emotional spending can be hard to spot because each purchase feels small. You may be spending to manage your mood if you:
- shop most often when you feel stressed, bored, low, or lonely;
- feel a rush while browsing or checking out, which fades quickly;
- buy things you do not use, or leave items unopened;
- hide purchases or play down what you spent;
- feel guilty or anxious after buying; or
- keep spending even when it causes money worries or arguments.
Emotional Spending Triggers
Triggers are the feelings and situations that come just before the urge to buy. Common ones include stress, boredom, loneliness, low mood, tiredness, and payday. Late-night scrolling and marketing emails can make the urge easier to act on.
Boredom and stress are especially common. In a survey of 1,000 UK adults by Moneyboat, 30% said boredom had pushed them to spend money they did not have, and 34% regretted stress-induced purchases. Almost a quarter (24%) said emotional spending had harmed their well-being. Read more in our report on how boredom and stress are driving emotional spending in the UK.
Retail Therapy Versus Compulsive Buying
Retail therapy is not always harmful. In three experiments published in the Journal of Consumer Psychology, making shopping choices helped to reduce lingering sadness, apparently by restoring a sense of personal control. The same benefit did not extend to anger.
Compulsive buying is different. It is driven by urges that feel hard to resist, it continues despite harm, and it often brings shame afterwards. A meta-analysis in Addiction estimated that about 5% of adults in representative samples show compulsive buying behaviour, with higher rates among younger people and women. A useful test is whether you choose to shop or feel you have to.
The cost of shopping addiction
Christine Wright, a behaviour change coach and owner of Habit Breaker, says that people with shopping addiction “often spend beyond their means”. She notes that although it may seem less harmful than drug or alcohol addiction, it “can and does create serious problems”, with money worries the most obvious. Some people borrow from family and friends to keep shopping and, because of shame and stigma, may not be honest about why they need the money.
How to stop compulsive shopping
- Identify your triggers: Work out what drives your shopping. Common triggers include depression, negativity, loneliness, and anxiety. A psychologist can help if the reasons are hard to untangle.
- Find another response: Feeling lonely? Call a friend. Anxious? Go for a walk to calm down.
- Pay with cash: Leaving cards at home and paying with cash can make you more aware of what you are spending, and when the cash runs out, you stop.
- Plan ahead: Write a shopping list and stick to it, which may cut down on impulse buys.
- Get support: For deeper problems or long-term low mood, speak to your GP or a mental health professional. Free debt advice is also available if money worries are building up.
How to Stop Emotional Spending
The aim is not to ban treats but to make spending a choice rather than a reflex. These strategies can help alongside the steps above:
- Name the feeling first: before you buy, ask what you are feeling and what you need. If the answer is rest, company, or comfort, a purchase may not meet that need.
- Build a mood menu: list free or low-cost things that lift your mood, such as a walk, a call to a friend, music, or a bath, and turn to it when the urge hits.
- Add friction: delete saved card details, log out of shopping apps, and turn off sale notifications so buying takes more effort.
- Set a guilt-free fun budget: a small, planned amount for treats removes the all-or-nothing thinking that often leads to splurges.
- Track mood and spending together: for two weeks, note what you bought and how you felt beforehand. Patterns usually appear quickly.
- Tackle the underlying stress: if money worries are part of the cycle, our guide to how financial stress affects mental health explains what helps.
FAQs
- Is compulsive shopping a mental health condition? Compulsive buying is recognised by many clinicians as a behavioural problem, though it is not a separate diagnosis in the main manuals.
- What causes compulsive shopping? Emotional needs, stress, low mood, and the brain’s reward response to buying can all play a part.
- How can I stop impulse buying? Plan purchases, wait 24 hours before buying, pay with cash, and unsubscribe from marketing emails.
- What is emotional spending? Emotional spending is buying to change how you feel, such as easing stress, boredom, or sadness, rather than buying because you need something.
- What are the signs of emotional spending? Shopping mostly when stressed or bored, feeling a brief high then guilt, hiding purchases, and buying things you do not use.
- What are common emotional spending triggers? Stress, boredom, loneliness, low mood, tiredness, payday, and marketing emails or late-night scrolling.
- What strategies help with emotional spending? Name the feeling before buying, keep a list of free mood boosters, remove saved card details, and set a small planned budget for treats.
Image credit: Freepik
