Saturday 14 November 2026About PsychregWrite for Us

Stories & Perspectives

Why Trying Not to Think About Smoking Makes Cigarette Cravings Stronger

by Himanshu Sharma · Updated

e-cigarette

In 1987 the psychologist Daniel Wegner asked a group of students to spend five minutes not thinking about a white bear. Each time the bear came to mind, they rang a bell, and they rang it often. When the ban was lifted, they thought about the bear more than students who had been free to think about it all along, as the original study on the paradoxical effects of thought suppression reported. Most people fighting cigarette cravings run the same experiment on themselves every day.

The usual advice is to stay busy and push the thought away until it passes. Anyone who has tried knows how that goes: the thought turns up with the morning tea and again after lunch, and each time it is pushed away it comes back a little stronger. It is the same pattern behind why trying not to think about something often backfires, and why thinking harder can make overthinking worse.

From thoughts to behaviour

Wegner showed that a suppressed thought returns, but he didn’t test whether suppression changes what people do. In 2010, James Erskine and colleagues at St George’s, University of London, tested exactly that with smokers. For three weeks, participants recorded how many cigarettes they smoked each day and how stressed they felt. In the middle week, one group was told to suppress any thoughts about smoking, a second was told to express them, and a control group simply carried on recording.

Play video

The result was a clear behavioural rebound. In the week after suppression, the suppression group smoked significantly more than either of the other groups. The same study found that people who habitually suppress unwanted thoughts had made more attempts to quit, and in practice more attempts means more times the quit didn’t hold.

That is an awkward finding for anyone who has been told to try harder. Trying harder, in the specific form of refusing to think about it, went hand in hand with smoking more.

Why pushing cigarette cravings away makes them stronger

Wegner later explained the effect as two processes running at once. One takes effort and keeps steering attention elsewhere. The other runs automatically, checking whether the forbidden thought has appeared, and that checking keeps the thought close to the surface. When someone is stressed or has had a drink, the steering weakens while the checking carries on, and the thought breaks through.

For a smoker, those low-effort moments are the very ones cigarettes have been tied to for years: the end of a meal, a difficult phone call, the first hour of a night out. It is much like the way an evening drink can become the way you switch off. The plan to simply not think about it fails exactly when it is needed most.

Working with the urge instead

If suppression is the problem, the alternative is to let the urge be there and watch it without obeying it. That is the idea behind mindfulness and acceptance-based approaches, and it has now been tested on cravings directly.

In a 2023 randomised trial at Yale, Corey Roos, Hedy Kober, and colleagues trained daily smokers to manage their cravings while looking at smoking-related images. One group practised mindful acceptance of the craving, another practised reappraisal (the familiar CBT step of rethinking the situation), and a third had no training. Over the first four weeks, both trained groups cut down more than the controls. Over the following months, smoking crept back up in the reappraisal group, while in the mindfulness group it held.

The trial is small, and quit rates were low in every group, so it doesn’t show that acceptance makes people stop. It does show the mechanism at work. People can learn to notice a craving without acting on it, and in this study that skill lasted longer than arguing with the craving did.

A different first step

Taken together, the research points to a quieter starting place: think about the cigarette more carefully, instead of trying not to think about it. When the urge comes, name it (there’s the after-lunch one), notice where you feel it, rate it from one to ten, and see what happens to it if you simply wait.

This is harder to sell than willpower, because it asks for curiosity, but it fits what the experiments found. A craving that is pushed away tends to come back, while a craving that is watched has nothing to push against. If you want extra help, the NHS Better Health quit smoking service offers free support, and combining behavioural support with stop smoking aids gives most people the best chance.

FAQs

  • Why do cigarette cravings get worse when I try to ignore them? Suppressing a thought keeps part of your mind checking for it, so the craving rebounds, especially under stress.
  • What is urge surfing? A mindfulness technique where you notice a craving, rate it, and let it rise and fall without acting on it.
  • How long does a cigarette craving last? Most individual cravings ease within a few minutes if you wait them out rather than act on them.