Saturday 07 November 2026About PsychregWrite for Us

Stories & Perspectives

Why Thinking Harder Makes Overthinking Worse

by Malik Sherjeel Awan · Updated

woman thinking

In my practice I often meet people who are very good at thinking. They are students, professionals, parents running busy households, and expatriates managing two lives at once. Many of them have tried to solve their overthinking the way they solve every other problem in their lives, which is by thinking about it harder.

So they analyse why they worry, argue with every anxious thought, and try to force the thoughts out. By the time we meet they are often exhausted, because none of it has worked. Anyone who has spent days replaying the conversation that hurt them will know how convincing this kind of mental effort can feel. Here I want to explain why thinking harder backfires, and what tends to help instead.

Overthinking is not deep thinking

Psychologists usually divide overthinking into two close relatives. Rumination tends to look backwards (“Why did I say that? What is wrong with me?”), while worry looks forwards (“What if it goes wrong?”). A major review by Susan Nolen-Hoeksema and colleagues summarised evidence that rumination worsens low mood, enhances negative thinking, impairs problem-solving, and erodes social support. It is also linked with anxiety, binge eating, binge drinking, and self-harm, as well as depression.

Play video

The trouble is that rumination feels productive, as if every lap of the same track brings you closer to an answer. But in a set of experiments by Sonja Lyubomirsky and Nolen-Hoeksema, people in a low mood who were asked to ruminate came up with less effective solutions to interpersonal problems than those who were asked to distract themselves for a few minutes. The distracted group solved problems about as well as people who were not low at all. So the late-night analysis is rarely your sharpest thinking, and often it is your least helpful.

Three ways thinking harder backfires

  • Pushing thoughts away makes them louder: In Daniel Wegner’s classic “white bear” study, people told not to think of a white bear could not manage it. Once the restriction was lifted, they thought about the bear more than people who had been free to think about it all along. Interestingly, those given a specific alternative to focus on showed less of this rebound, which suggests that suppression fails while redirection helps.
  • Asking “why” keeps you stuck: Edward Watkins’ review of constructive and unconstructive repetitive thought suggests that the same mental habit can help or harm depending on how it is done. Abstract, evaluative thinking (“Why am I like this?”) tends to be unhelpful, while concrete, specific thinking (“What exactly happened, and what is one thing I can do next?”) is more likely to be useful.
  • Searching for certainty becomes a safety behaviour: As I wrote in my earlier article on health anxiety and the reassurance trap, reassurance brings relief that does not last. A study by Paul Salkovskis and Osamu Kobori found that for people with OCD or panic disorder, reassurance brings short-term relief followed by the return of anxiety and the urge to seek more. Going over a problem again and again in your head is often the same process turned inwards. You are reassuring yourself, and it wears off just as quickly.

What helps instead

The aim is not to stop thinking but to change your relationship with thinking. In practice, these four steps are a good place to start.

  1. Label the process, not the content: Instead of engaging with the fifth version of “What if I fail?”, simply notice, “I’m ruminating again”. Naming the process creates a little distance and makes it easier to choose what to do next.
  2. Schedule your worry: Set aside a fixed 15 to 20 minutes each day, well away from bedtime. When a worry appears at other times, note it down and postpone it until then. The idea goes back to early stimulus control work by Thomas Borkovec and colleagues, and a 2025 randomised controlled trial found that people who added specific “if-then” plans to worry postponement reported spending less time worrying than those who used postponement alone. Sleep outcomes did not change in that trial, so treat this as a tool for worry rather than a cure for poor sleep.
  3. Go concrete: When you do think about a problem, write down one specific next step and a time to do it. If you cannot find one, the problem may be one to accept for now rather than solve.
  4. Redirect, don’t suppress: Pick an absorbing activity in advance, such as a walk, a phone call, or a task that needs your hands. Wegner’s findings suggest that a planned alternative works better than simply trying not to think.

Play video

If overthinking has been affecting your sleep, work, or relationships for weeks at a time, or is part of low mood or anxiety, it is worth speaking to a qualified mental health professional. Rumination and worry are well understood, and structured psychological approaches are designed to address them.

The bottom line

Overthinking is not a sign that you are not thinking enough. It usually means you are asking thinking to do a job it cannot do, which is to remove uncertainty. The way out is rarely a better argument. It is learning, gently and repeatedly, to let a thought be there without having to answer it.

FAQs

  • Why does overthinking make me feel worse? Rumination feels like problem-solving, but research shows it deepens low mood, feeds negative thinking, and weakens your ability to find good solutions to everyday problems.
  • Is rumination the same as worry? Both are forms of overthinking, but rumination dwells on the past and asks why something happened, while worry looks ahead to what might go wrong.
  • Does trying not to think about something work? Usually not. In Daniel Wegner’s white bear study, suppressed thoughts came back more strongly, whereas focusing on a planned alternative reduced the rebound.
  • What is worry postponement? It means saving your worries for a fixed 15 to 20 minutes each day and noting them down when they appear at other times, and a 2025 trial found that adding “if-then” plans cut the time people spent worrying.