What is the manosphere? It is the name given to a sprawling collection of online spaces, from video channels and podcasts to forums and paid courses, that tell boys and young men what it means to be a man. The messages often mix fitness, money, and dating advice with the claim that men are under attack and that women and feminism are to blame.
The manosphere has no single leader, website, or membership list. It is better understood as an ecosystem in which different creators compete for attention, and in which the most provocative content tends to travel furthest.
This week the subject moved firmly into health policy. A new Viewpoint in The Lancet argues that the manosphere should be treated as a public health problem, and that the response should focus on why boys are drawn in, not on blaming them for it.
What Is the Manosphere?
In their paper, Reframing the manosphere: a public health response to a commercial ecosystem, Professor Sarah Hawkes and Professor Kent Buse define the manosphere as a diffuse commercial ecosystem and loose collection of online communities united by shared beliefs about masculinity, misogyny, and male victimisation. They describe how it has become a lucrative industry that profits from promoting what they call the most extreme expressions of misogyny and aggrieved masculinity.
According to reporting in The Guardian, the authors also note that men’s problems are framed in these spaces as the result of feminism rather than structural conditions, and that masculine identity is sold back to boys through products and paid content. In other words, the pain is real, but the explanation on offer is designed to keep viewers engaged and spending.
Why the Manosphere Draws in Boys and Young Men
The authors are clear that the pull is real. In the Global 50/50 press release on the paper, they point to several pressures that can leave young men searching for answers:
- Loneliness: Many boys and young men report intense isolation and a lack of close friendships.
- Money worries: Insecure work and an uncertain future can make promises of quick wealth very appealing.
- Dropping out of education: Growing disengagement from school and college among boys around the world leaves some without direction.
- Belonging: Online communities offer identity, purpose, and a simple explanation for why life feels hard.
Professor Hawkes put it plainly, saying that the manosphere offers boys and young men belonging, identity, and an explanation for why life feels hard, and that those needs are real. Earlier research on incel online communities has similarly found deep psychological distress alongside misogyny.
How the Manosphere Harms Boys and Young Men
Although the manosphere presents itself as a guide to becoming stronger, the authors say the risks for the boys who engage with it include poor mental health, body image problems, and a reluctance to seek professional help. Messages that equate manhood with dominance and emotional control can make it harder for boys to admit they are struggling.
The authors describe this as delegitimising help-seeking in boys and men. When asking for support is framed as weakness, a young person may stay silent at the very moment he most needs someone to talk to.
How the Manosphere Harms Women and Girls
The harms do not stop with boys. The researchers warn that the manosphere normalises deeply misogynistic attitudes, contributing to an environment in which violence against women and girls is more readily accepted. Girls and women can experience this as harassment online, hostility at school, and pressure in relationships.
What the Lancet Viewpoint Proposes
The authors argue that the manosphere should be treated like other commercial health harms, such as tobacco and ultra-processed food. Professor Buse described it as a business model, not a fringe, in which outrage and grievance are good for business. He added that boys and men are not the problem, and that the problem is the conditions that leave them isolated and without a secure future, and the companies that profit from their anger and insecurity.
The Viewpoint sets out six priorities:
- Tackle root causes: Address educational marginalisation, social exclusion, and isolation among boys and young men.
- Work across sectors: Link health systems with schools and other services that routinely reach boys.
- Avoid blaming boys: Use messages that do not frame masculinity as inherently toxic, including pre-bunking co-designed with boys and men.
- Regulate platforms: Focus on the structures and incentives that generate harm rather than on the individuals exposed to it.
- Invest in research: Monitor the changing digital world and evaluate what works, including unintended effects.
- Confront misogyny: Challenge the wider anti-equality prejudices that the manosphere amplifies.
The UK Context and the Online Safety Act
The paper arrives as the UK implements the Online Safety Act, which places new duties on platforms to protect users, particularly children, from harmful content. The authors warn that removing harmful posts alone will not stop the spread of online misogyny, and that governments must also deal with the reasons young men go looking for these spaces.
What Critics and Other Voices Say
Not everyone frames the issue the same way. Mark Brooks of the Centre for Policy Research on Men and Boys welcomed the public health approach but told The Guardian that the debate has too often positioned all men and boys as a problem, ignoring the economic, educational, and cultural challenges that drive engagement. He also stressed that not all boys engage with this content equally.
The authors themselves acknowledge limits to the smoking comparison. They note that the manosphere is not a single product, that its harms are less directly demonstrable, and that online engagement has legitimate and beneficial uses. Professor Buse also anticipates pushback that regulation is an attack on freedom, which he compares to the playbook that served the tobacco industry. Ongoing debate about the term toxic masculinity shows how sensitive the language can be.
Practical Steps for Parents and Teachers
You do not need to be an expert to help. These approaches reflect the spirit of the Lancet recommendations:
- Stay curious: Ask what your son or pupil is watching and why they like it, without mocking or lecturing.
- Talk about the business model: Explain that outrage earns money, so creators have a reason to say extreme things.
- Offer real belonging: Encourage clubs, sport, volunteering, and friendships that meet the same need for identity offline.
- Model help-seeking: Show that talking about feelings and asking for help is a strength, not a weakness.
- Teach critical thinking: Practise spotting claims that blame one group for everything and asking what evidence supports them.
Where to Get Support
If a young man in your life is struggling, encourage him to talk to someone he trusts or to a GP. CALM offers support for anyone who is struggling on 0800 58 58 58, and Samaritans can be reached free on 116 123 at any time. If someone is in immediate danger, call 999.
FAQs
- Is the manosphere bad? Not every creator or video is harmful, but researchers link the wider ecosystem to poor mental health in boys and to attitudes that make violence against women more acceptable.
- Is the manosphere still a thing? Yes. Experts writing in The Lancet in October 2026 describe it as a growing, profitable online industry, which is why they call for a public health response.
- How do I talk to my son about the manosphere? Start with curiosity rather than criticism, ask what he finds appealing, and talk about how creators make money from outrage.
- What does the Lancet paper say about blaming boys? It argues that boys and men are not the problem, and that the focus should be on the conditions and companies that profit from their insecurity.
Takeaway
The manosphere is a commercial ecosystem that sells boys a simple story about why life feels hard, and public health experts now say it deserves the same serious response as other commercial health harms. That response should tackle loneliness, insecurity, and platform incentives rather than blame boys. Parents and teachers can make the biggest difference by listening, explaining the business model, and helping boys find belonging offline.











