Home Mental Health & Well-Being Study Reveals 19.6% of Suicide Attempters Lacked Prior Psychiatric Disorders

Study Reveals 19.6% of Suicide Attempters Lacked Prior Psychiatric Disorders

Reading Time: 2 minutes

A recent study published in JAMA Psychiatry has revealed that a considerable proportion of individuals who attempt suicide do so without any prior psychiatric disorder. This discovery challenges the conventional understanding of suicide risk factors and suggests the need for broader suicide prevention strategies.

The study, led by Maria A. Oquendo, MD and her team at the Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, utilised data from the National Epidemiologic Study of Addictions and Related Conditions III (NESARC-III). This large, nationally representative survey of 1948 US adults who reported lifetime suicide attempts provided a detailed look at the prevalence of suicide attempts among those without psychiatric diagnoses.

Key findings from the study include:

  • Approximately 19.6% of individuals who attempted suicide did not meet the criteria for any psychiatric disorder at the time of their first attempt.
  • Among those with lifetime psychiatric disorders, 13.4% made their first suicide attempt before the onset of any psychiatric condition.
  • No significant differences were found in the prevalence of suicide attempts among healthy volunteers across different age groups or between males and females.

These findings suggest that current suicide prevention strategies, which often focus primarily on individuals with identified psychiatric conditions, may miss a significant portion of the at-risk population. The study’s authors argue that this oversight could be a critical gap in efforts to reduce suicide rates.

The study’s results call into question the effectiveness of limiting suicide risk screening to psychiatric populations. Currently, institutions like The Joint Commission require suicide risk assessments primarily for patients identified as having suicidal ideation or other psychiatric symptoms. But this practice may be insufficient to identify all individuals at risk of suicide.

The researchers recommend considering broader and more inclusive screening methods. This could involve routine screening for suicide risk in various settings, including primary care, educational institutions, and workplaces, to ensure that individuals without apparent psychiatric disorders are also identified and supported.

From a nosological perspective, the findings challenge the traditional view that suicidal behaviour is inherently linked to psychiatric disorders such as major depressive disorder or borderline personality disorder. The study suggests that suicidal behaviour may sometimes occur independently of these conditions, warranting further investigation into its classification and management.

Dr Oquendo and her team argue that recognising suicidal behaviour as a distinct clinical entity could improve understanding and treatment.

While the study provides significant insights, it also has limitations. The NESARC-III relies on retrospective self-reporting, which can be affected by recall bias and underreporting of psychiatric symptoms and suicide attempts. Additionally, some less common psychiatric diagnoses were not assessed, which may influence the findings.

The authors call for further research to confirm these results and explore the underlying factors contributing to suicide attempts among psychiatrically healthy individuals. They also highlight the need for studies investigating the effectiveness of broader suicide risk screening and intervention strategies.

© Copyright 2014–2034 Psychreg Ltd