Saturday 14 November 2026About PsychregWrite for Us

Society

Sociologist Argues Capitalism Lies Behind Rising Mental Illness Diagnoses

by Psychreg News Team · Updated

psychiatry

Original studyPsychreg Journal of Psychology, 2017Read the paper →

Rates of diagnosed mental illness have risen sharply in recent decades, and the language of disorder is now heard in homes, classrooms and offices. Many see this as a sign of greater awareness. A sociologist argues instead that the rise has much to do with the needs of modern capitalism.

The argument is set out in an interview about a book titled Psychiatric Hegemony: A Marxist Theory of Mental Illness, written by a sociologist at the University of Auckland. The interview appears in Psychreg Journal of Psychology. It was carried out by the journal’s editor.

The book offers a Marxist critique of the business of mental health. It argues that neoliberal capitalism wants productive, self-governing citizens, and that this has helped ideas about mental illness spread far beyond the psychiatric hospital.

Hegemony describes a situation in which the values of a ruling group come to seem natural and common sense. In this view, psychiatric thinking has become so dominant that everyone is now seen as a subject at risk of mental disorder.

The book ranges from schizophrenia and hysteria to ADHD and borderline personality disorder. It covers treatments from spinning chairs and lobotomies to electric shock and antidepressants. It also discusses the locking up of working class women in the 19th century and the treatment of prisoners in the war on terror.

In the interview, the author says that people working in psychiatry should still read the book. He says it asks the same questions they do, such as what mental illness is, why rates are rising, and why recovery rates remain low. He argues that his analysis is open to evidence like any other science.

To support his case, the author says he traced the history of the mental health professions and studied the text of the diagnostic manual used by psychiatrists. He argues that diagnostic categories have come to reflect the demands of neoliberalism more and more over time.

The interview has clear limits. It presents one scholar’s theory and his own account of his book, rather than new research tested against other views. Many psychiatrists would dispute the claim that diagnoses mainly serve economic ends.

The author says his is not the first Marxist account of mental health but is the most comprehensive. He adds that he was finishing a large edited handbook on critical mental health, which aims to bring critical thinking back to the heart of research on mental illness.