Home Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy New Study Says Differentiating Autism from Trauma Symptoms Requires Comprehensive, Interdisciplinary Assessment

New Study Says Differentiating Autism from Trauma Symptoms Requires Comprehensive, Interdisciplinary Assessment

Reading Time: 2 minutes

A recent clinical case study conducted by researchers from Oslo University Hospital sheds light on the intricate challenges faced when diagnosing autism in individuals with a history of early traumatisation. The study, published in the journal Advances in Autism, explores the complex interplay between autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and trauma-related symptoms, which often complicates accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment.

The case study focuses on a 24-year-old woman, referred to as “Rebecca” for anonymity, who had previously been diagnosed with mild intellectual disability, borderline personality disorder (BPD), and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The primary aim of the study was to delineate between the symptoms of autism and those arising from early trauma, ensuring a more accurate diagnosis, which is critical for effective treatment and support.

Rebecca’s case underscores the diagnostic conundrum that arises when autism and trauma-related symptoms coexist. The symptoms of autism – such as difficulties in social interaction and communication, and repetitive behaviours – can overlap significantly with trauma responses like avoidance, hyperarousal, and emotional dysregulation. This overlap often leads to misdiagnosis, where trauma symptoms might be wrongly attributed to autism, or vice versa, leading to inadequate or misdirected treatment plans.

The researchers employed a comprehensive, multi-informant assessment strategy that included:

  • Review of previous records. An extensive review of Rebecca’s medical, psychological, and social service records.
  • Use of multiple diagnostic tools. Tools such as the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ados), the Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised (ADI-R), and various scales for intellectual and adaptive functioning were utilised. However, the standard completion of these tools was often challenging due to the complexity of her conditions.
  • Clinical observations. Direct observations by experienced clinicians to gather nuanced insights into Rebecca’s behaviours and symptoms.

Rebecca’s trauma-related symptoms had previously overshadowed her diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder, but the thorough evaluation proved that she did in fact meet the criteria. Her difficulties with social interaction and communication, along with repetitive behaviours, were consistent with autism and distinct from those typically seen in individuals with intellectual disabilities and PTSD.

Additionally, it was determined that Rebecca’s symptoms of PTSD were more accurately described as complex PTSD, reflecting the prolonged and repetitive nature of her trauma. This re-evaluation led to the removal of the BPD diagnosis, which had previously influenced her treatment plan and the perceptions of her care providers.

Following the revised diagnoses, the treatment approach for Rebecca was adjusted to incorporate trauma-informed care (TIC). This approach focuses on creating a safe and supportive environment that acknowledges and addresses the impact of trauma on her behaviour and mental health. Key elements included:

  • Consistency and predictability. Establishing joint routines among direct service providers (DSPs) will help Rebecca feel secure and understood.
  • Empowerment and choice. Providing Rebecca with choices and involving her in decision-making processes to counteract feelings of powerlessness.
  • Validation and support. Emphasising the need for validation and explicit confirmation of safety to help build trust and reduce anxiety.

The study highlights the critical need for mental health professionals to be aware of the potential for diagnostic overshadowing in cases where autism and early trauma intersect. It emphasises the importance of comprehensive, interdisciplinary assessments that consider the full scope of an individual’s history and symptoms. Misdiagnoses can lead to inappropriate interventions, potentially exacerbating the very symptoms they aim to alleviate.

For Rebecca, the revised diagnoses have paved the way for more tailored and effective support, highlighting the broader implications for individuals with similar dual diagnoses. The study calls for increased awareness and specialised training for professionals working with populations at the intersection of autism and trauma, to ensure accurate diagnoses and the provision of appropriate, holistic care.

© Copyright 2014–2034 Psychreg Ltd