Original studyPsychreg Journal of Psychology, 2017Read the paper →
Theatre has long been a place where societies explore what is hard to say out loud. In Iran, where the stage operates under close watch, that can take particular courage. A psychoanalytic commentary looks at a Tehran play that tackled power, violence and the relationship between adults and children.
A psychoanalyst at Université Côte d’Azur in France wrote the commentary after attending the play with its author, a young Iranian director who founded the Radical 14 Troupe. Reflecting on what prompted his interest, he said: “It is this idea of afterwardness that will guide these few lines. The year is 2026. I made my first trip to Iran in the summer of 1992, around the time Hashemi Rafsanjani took office as president. That trip was followed by two more, then a long absence, before I returned several years in a row starting in 2014, up until my last trip in Tehran for the Third Congress of Psychoanalysis in 2019. I believe that this play alone concentrated all the profound transformations of Iranian society, but that it also revealed all the tension and radicalism inherent in the dynamics of that society.
“The title Fatherless resonated deeply with the analyst regarding the essential question of primary identification with the father according to Freud, a theme implied in his Three Essays and even more clearly articulated in Totem and Taboo and, in Lacan, to the concept, which is ultimately not so far removed provided one looks beyond the formula, of the foreclosure of the Name-of-the-Father. Both refer to the abolition of this identification. Freud even speaks, in connection with the Schreber case, of Das Aufgehobene, which means clearly which is abolished and not repressed.”
The piece appears in Psychreg Journal of Psychology. It is followed by an interview with the playwright, carried out and translated by a trainee psychoanalyst at the Freudian Group of Tehran.
The play, Fatherless, ran to full houses in April and May 2017 in a basement studio at the City Theatre Complex in central Tehran. It is based on a well-known Iranian folk tale of young goats and a wolf, which is linked to one of Aesop’s fables.
Six young actors played the goats, their mother, the wolf and the wolf’s son. The stage was reduced to a dark staircase with doors that opened, closed and slammed. The commentary describes blood, cannibalism, howling and anxiety, and calls the production subtly mad and intelligently subversive.
Psychoanalysis is a school of thought that looks at hidden wishes and early experiences to explain behaviour. The commentary reads the play through the work of the French psychoanalyst Jean Laplanche, who argued that adults pass unconscious sexual messages to children without meaning to. In the play, that imbalance of power between adults and children is shown boldly.
The commentary notes that such a show would surprise no one in London or Berlin. It argues that staging it in the capital of the Islamic Republic of Iran, with symbols, analytical references and political messages, made it a real cultural event. On the broader implications, he noted: “It is difficult to answer this very material question, especially in light of the current and dramatic events in Iran. Did the play foreshadow, as artists and poets often sense before scientists do, the search for and need for a symbolic father, whose absence, as analytical and psychiatric theory teaches, can lead to psychosis? In direct relation to this issue, I would like to mention my assessment of the situation that I shared with an advisor at the French Embassy in Iran during one of my most recent trips to the country: namely, that women and young people are now the driving force behind change in Iran. I had even sketched out a speculative metaphor: the regime’s walls were solid, but more and more people, namely women and youth, were pouring into the room, and eventually they would cause the walls to crack or even collapse under the pressure.”
In the interview, the playwright says he prefers not to explain the message of his work, because talking about it can spoil it. He suggests that his next play may be lighter, given the dark and aggressive mood of this one. He also says that audiences from any language or culture could relate to it.
The piece has clear limits. It is a personal commentary and interview rather than a research study, and it reflects the views of people who attended and created the play.
Psychoanalysis has a growing following in Iran. This commentary offers a rare look at how its ideas are being used to read new Iranian theatre. Looking ahead, he observed: “Fundamental research in psychoanalysis is just as essential as clinical practice. Freud himself preferred the former, even though, for material reasons, namely to support his large family, he analysed patients for several hours a day. In this fatherless environment, fellow psychiatrists and psychoanalysts have even gone so far as to propose the concept of ordinary psychosis, which is, according to them, on the rise, particularly among adolescents: a virtually invisible psychosis because it lacks the traditional symptoms listed in the DSM: no hallucinations, no delusions, and only a few linguistic or even social difficulties. Moreover, the 2013 DSM-5 mentions attenuated psychosis in its appendices, which it had intended to classify under a new category, yet another one, of schizophrenia, obviously for pharmacological reasons. This effort was unsuccessful.”












