Home Blog Psychology Hidden Struggles Revealed: PhD Students’ Blogposts Highlight Mental Health Challenges

Hidden Struggles Revealed: PhD Students’ Blogposts Highlight Mental Health Challenges

Published: Last updated:
Reading Time: 3 minutes

The pursuit of a PhD is often seen as the pinnacle of academic achievement, a journey brimming with intellectual rigour and discovery. But beneath this veneer of academic endeavour lies a less discussed aspect of PhD life: the mental health and well-being of doctoral candidates.

In a recent study published in the journal Studies in Continuing Education, researchers delved into the personal blogposts of PhD students, uncovering the often-hidden struggles and stressors they face.

PhD studies, marked by their intensity and high demands, bring with them a unique set of stressors. These range from supervisory relationships, academic community dynamics, to resource availability. The study found that PhD students often grapple with hierarchical institutional cultures and specific work demands, contributing to heightened mental health risks.

Unlike traditional self-reported questionnaires, blogposts offer a more nuanced and personal account of the doctoral journey. These narratives reveal the internal conflicts and pressures PhD students face, which often stay hidden in more formal academic discussions. The thematic analysis of 94 blogposts in English, Spanish, and Korean provided an intimate look into the daily struggles of doctoral students.

The study highlighted significant cultural differences in the experience of stressors among PhD students. Spanish and Korean students, for instance, pointed out issues related to funding, academic culture, and gender stereotypes. The Korean sample specifically highlighted the complexities of supervisory relationships, a factor less emphasised in English blogposts.

A striking theme across the blogposts was the emphasis on maintaining mental and physical well-being as a key to higher productivity. Negative mental states such as stress, anxiety, and depression were prevalent among the students. The study underscores the importance of recognising and addressing mental health concerns within academic settings to promote a healthier environment for doctoral candidates.

Marek Urban, PhD, a researcher from the Czech Academy of Sciences, sheds further light on the study’s motivations and findings.

He explained: “This study was born out of the unique perspective of two international PhD students and me as a supervisor; we are all coming from three distinct cultures: Latin America, South Korea and Central Europe.

“As I saw the struggles our own Ph.D. students face, we conducted this research to shed light on the complexities of the PhD experience, beyond the usual academic metrics and achievements. Recognising the rising concerns around mental health in academia, we aimed to explore the lived experiences of doctoral students in a more nuanced and personal way.

“By analysing blogposts, we sought to capture the authentic voices of students from diverse cultural backgrounds, providing a more comprehensive understanding of their challenges, coping strategies, and the impact of cultural nuances on their academic journey.”

Urban’s team’s analysis revealed that despite the universal challenges of PhD studies, such as stress and anxiety and hierarchical academical structure or pressure to perform, students employ a variety of coping mechanisms, including the emphasis on self-care and mental well-being.

But he pointed out: “We found that these self-care practices are often viewed as means to enhance productivity rather than as valuable for personal well-being. This highlights a concerning trend in academia, where the pressure to succeed can overshadow the importance of mental health.

“The study also underscored the significance of cultural context, revealing how students from different backgrounds perceive and handle academic stress differently. These insights call for a more holistic and culturally sensitive approach to supporting PhD students, emphasising the need to value well-being as much as academic accomplishments.”

“Looking ahead,” Urban adds, “we plan to delve deeper into the experiences of international PhD students through in-depth phenomenological interviews. Our next study aims to explore the personal narratives of these students, providing a more detailed understanding of their journey through academia.

“By focusing on the lived experiences of international PhD students, we hope to uncover the deeper emotional and psychological facets of their academic endeavours, further contributing to the development of supportive, inclusive, and well-being-focused academic environments. This ongoing research not only reflects our commitment to improving the Ph.D. experience but also underscores the importance of listening to and understanding the diverse voices of doctoral students worldwide.”

Addressing mental health concerns and providing a holistic support system for PhD students is paramount. As the pursuit of academic excellence continues to evolve, it is imperative to balance it with the well-being of those at its core – the students.

© Copyright 2014–2034 Psychreg Ltd