Saturday 14 November 2026About PsychregWrite for Us

Society

Critical Mental Health Handbook Offers Students a Useful Summary, Review Says

by Psychreg News Team · Updated

library shelves

Original studyPsychreg Journal of Psychology, 2018Read the paper →

Debates about how mental illness is defined and treated have rumbled on since the 1970s, yet critical voices remain on the edges of mainstream psychiatry. A major handbook set out to gather them in one place. A new review says it does that well for students, but rarely moves the argument on.

The review, by a reviewer at Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Trust, appears in Psychreg Journal of Psychology. It assesses the Routledge International Handbook of Critical Mental Health, a book with many contributors edited by a sociologist at the University of Auckland. The editor had already spoken to the journal twice, about this book and about an earlier one on Marxist theory and mental illness.

According to the review, the editor put the collection together out of frustration at the general lack of critical engagement in the sociology of mental health. Socially critical views have often been dismissed as an embarrassing hangover from the 1970s, partly because of their association with anti-psychiatry. The editor makes clear the book is not anti-psychiatry in that sense, although one chapter reclaims the term.

Critical mental health is an approach that questions how mental illness is defined and treated, and whose interests those practices serve. Anti-psychiatry was a movement, prominent in the 1960s and 1970s, that challenged the authority and methods of psychiatry. A physicalist view holds that mental illness has a bodily basis, for example in the brain.

The editor’s own chapter looks at Marxist theory. He suggests there may be merit in viewing mental illness as a result of the alienating conditions of capitalism, but urges Marxists to focus on how the mental health system supports the economic and political interests of the ruling classes.

The reviewer says many chapters give useful and reasonably comprehensive summaries of critical mental health studies, especially for students, and recommends the book on that basis. Few chapters, however, take the debate forward, and most confine themselves to summarising the existing literature. The reviewer would have liked more engagement with mainstream views.

The review notes the editor’s own point that the science of mental illness is as contested now as it was in the 1970s. Even so, the reviewer expects critical approaches to stay on the margins, and believes the wish to find a physical basis for mental illness will never go away.

The review has clear limits. It is a short, personal assessment of a long book and does not discuss individual chapters in detail.

The handbook was also the subject of an earlier interview with its editor, covered in our report on how a new handbook challenges the Western approach to mental health.

The reviewer hopes that students who read the book to understand the many ways critical approaches have been applied may be able to move the field beyond its current position.