Saturday 07 November 2026About PsychregWrite for Us

Mental Health

Can You Tell if Someone Is Lying from Their Face? What the Elizabeth Holmes Stare Teaches Us

by Dennis Relojo-Howell ·

woman face

Can you tell if someone is lying from their face? Mostly, no. Research on how to tell if someone is lying finds that people are only slightly better than chance, and the cues most of us trust, such as eye contact or fidgeting, are weak or unrelated to lying.

The question is back in the news because of You Can See Everything, the A24 documentary about the Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes, directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. According to ABC News, it opened in US cinemas on 16th October 2026, and Variety reports that it reaches UK and Irish cinemas on 20th November 2026. The film follows Holmes in the weeks before she reported to prison in 2023, after she was found guilty in January 2022 of four counts of wire fraud and conspiracy to commit wire fraud against investors.

Viewers are divided over how to read Holmes on screen. A therapist trained in facial cues told Today that, even for someone trained in this, the faces in the film were hard to read, especially in the first half, and added that body language is not always an accurate read of how someone is feeling. That caution is the point of this article: a stare is easy to notice and hard to interpret, and nothing here is a judgement on Holmes beyond what a court has found.

Can you tell if someone is lying from their face?

The best evidence comes from a 2006 meta-analysis by Charles Bond and Bella DePaulo in Personality and Social Psychology Review. It pooled research from 206 documents and 24,483 judges, in which people tried to tell lies from truths in real time with no special aids or training, and you can find the 2006 meta-analysis through its DOI link.

On average, people got 54% of judgements right, correctly classifying 47% of lies as deceptive and 61% of truths as honest. That is only 4 points better than the 50% a coin toss would give, and people were better at recognising truths than at catching lies. The same review found that people were more accurate judging audible than visible lies, and that individuals tend to regard the people they are talking to as honest. For more on why people lie and why catching them is so hard, see a guide to why people lie and what psychology says about deception.

Why do eye contact and fidgeting make poor lie detectors?

A 2003 meta-analysis by Bella DePaulo and colleagues in Psychological Bulletin combined 1,338 estimates of 158 possible cues to deception. For the cue most people reach for first, the combined effect of eye contact across 32 estimates was almost exactly zero, and the authors concluded that there is no clear relationship between fidgeting and lying. You can read the cues to deception review via its DOI link.

Some patterns did appear. On average, liars were less forthcoming, told less compelling stories, and seemed more tense, and their accounts contained fewer ordinary imperfections. But many behaviours showed no link, or only a weak one, to deceit.

A 2019 review by Aldert Vrij and colleagues in Annual Review of Psychology reached a similar conclusion: the nonverbal cues to deceit discovered so far are faint and unreliable, and people are mediocre lie catchers when they pay attention to behaviour. You can see the Reading Lies review through its DOI link. Blinking is another popular supposed tell, and an earlier article on blinking, stress, and lying shows how often such patterns are discussed, but the same caution applies to any single cue.

Why do we trust a fixed stare as a sign of lying?

The belief that a gaze gives lies away is remarkably widespread. The Global Deception Research Team surveyed people in 75 countries and 43 languages and found a dominant pan-cultural stereotype: that liars avert their gaze. Vrij and colleagues add that misbeliefs about nonverbal behaviour and deception appear very hard to debunk, and you can see the A World of Lies survey for the global findings.

Notice that the common belief says liars look away, yet an unbroken stare is what people are picking over after the film. Once you suspect someone, it is easy to find a meaning in whichever way their gaze goes, which is a reason to be wary of reading it.

Two findings from the Bond and DePaulo review also help. People tend to regard others as honest, and they appear deceptive when they are motivated to be believed, so a person who is trying hard to seem sincere can look suspicious without lying. Motivation to be believed can distort the very cues we think we are reading.

How to tell if someone is lying and what actually helps

No method is foolproof, but the research points to what people say rather than how they look. In a small experiment by Galit Nahari, Aldert Vrij, and Ronald Fisher, published in Legal and Criminological Psychology, 38 people wrote about their activities over a recent 30-minute period, telling the truth or lying. Liars included fewer details that could be verified and the same number of details that could not, and counting verifiable details classified 79% of the participants correctly, as described in the verifiability study.

Another approach is to make lying harder. In two experiments by Vrij and colleagues in Law and Human Behavior, 80 mock suspects told the truth or lied about a staged event, and those asked to tell their story in reverse order showed many more cues to deceit than those who told it in order. When 55 police officers then watched a selection of the interviews, asking for the story in reverse order improved their ability to detect deception without biasing their judgements, according to the reverse-order study. A piece on detecting deception, using The Traitors as its example explains how this kind of cognitive load works.

Both studies were small and used staged situations, so they are pointers, not guarantees. In everyday life, the practical lessons drawn from this research are modest:

  • Ask for detail: Open questions give people room to say more, and names, places, and times can be checked later.
  • Check the facts: An account that holds up against what you can verify is more useful than one that merely looks confident.
  • Hold your hunch lightly: Nervousness, a long pause, or a fixed stare can come from stress, so treat unease as a prompt to look into things, not as proof.

What can a documentary tell us about lying?

The documented facts about Holmes are those of the case: she was found guilty in January 2022 of four counts of wire fraud and conspiracy to commit wire fraud against investors, and she began her prison sentence in 2023. A conviction rests on evidence presented in court, not on how someone looks on camera.

According to ABC News, Holmes’s partner, Billy Evans, said the idea behind the film was “here she is. See her and make up your own mind”. That is a fair description of what a close-up invites, but a close-up gives us plenty of face to read and no extra information about what someone knows, and the research above suggests that reading it is little better than guessing.

FAQs

  • Can you tell if someone is lying from their face? Not reliably. In a review of 206 documents, people judged lies and truths correctly 54% of the time, and a 2003 meta-analysis found almost no link between eye contact and lying.
  • Do liars avoid eye contact? Many people around the world believe so, but across 32 estimates in a 2003 meta-analysis the combined effect of eye contact was almost exactly zero.
  • How can you tell if someone is lying? There is no foolproof sign. The research above points to asking open questions, looking at whether an account contains details that can be checked, and verifying facts, rather than judging a face.
  • Can a documentary show whether Elizabeth Holmes is lying? No. A film cannot show what someone knows or intends. The documented facts are that Holmes was found guilty in January 2022 of four counts of wire fraud and conspiracy to commit wire fraud against investors, and her face on screen adds nothing to that.

Takeaway

Reading a face for lies is little better than guessing, and a fixed stare, like any single cue, is far too weak to carry the weight we put on it. If you need to judge whether something is true, ask for details that can be checked, check them, and hold your own hunches lightly. As for Elizabeth Holmes, the documented facts are those of her conviction, and how she looks on screen does not add to them.