To follow up on prior writing, I wanted to share more reflections (coming from an autistic person myself). Assistance with activities of daily living (ADL) is often central when discussing the realities of autism, so I felt it important to include that perspective here. This is an enormous piece and is a product of my autistic overthinking and cognitive looping/repetitive thinking.
The most important insight to take from this entire piece (and the endless hours I’ve spent learning from autistics and people close to them) is this:
Level 0/subclinical autism is not disabling. But autism spectrum disorder (ASD) at levels 1, 2, and 3 is disabling.
The most important insight I wanna share with other autistics is this:
How you feel about your own experience of autism is a deeply personal matter, and absolutely nobody else – family, friends, other autists, autism communities or organisations, health providers, etc. – can tell you differently.
The most important section is “What does level 3 autism really look like (in real life)?”
Obviously, the very last thing I intend to do is add to the collective harms that autistic people face. And there are a lot of harms of virtually all kinds imaginable. From hearing hundreds of stories, I know very well the wide-ranging kinds of abuse, discrimination, bullying, adversities, etc. that many autistics (but not all) face.
Obviously, I don’t want to add to the stigma surrounding autism when I know the shit we go through already (lots of autistics have lost their lives, been murdered, etc.)
Of course, I would love for all autistics (and their non-autistic carers) to feel happy about, proud of, and at peace with autism. Of course, I wish that all autists had the very best, healthiest lives possible for themselves, had all their support needs met, and that societies did the most possible to help them (e.g., accessibility, accommodations).
But having read, watched, and heard hundreds of stories, from all around the world (six continents), from those across the spectrum (and allistics adjacent to them), the fact is that these wishes just aren’t the reality for a lot of autists and their carers.
It’s called a spectrum disorder/condition for a reason.
Obviously (there are a lot of “obviouslys”), there is a lot of compassion, care, understanding, support, and validation from autistics towards other autistics. They’ve helped me a lot, and I truly appreciate that. I will always be deeply grateful to the autistic community – and the wider disabled community – for helping me see who I am. I’m glad they’re fighting for their rights. They’ve taught me how to advocate for and protect myself.
The vast majority of autistic people are supportive, reasonable, sensible people.
Denying autism and then romanticising it
I think the reason that people (you and everyone else) would rather blame your autism-related challenges on “personality flaws” or “bad behaviour” is because you can change and control those things.
On the other hand, when you’re diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder (ASD), everyone has to acknowledge that you’re living with a lifelong, incurable neurodevelopmental condition. That’s a much bigger pill to swallow. (Mental health conditions you can recover from.)
So, to make everyone feel better, they go to the extreme with toxic positivity and say stuff like the following (about all autistic people, the millions of us):
Autistic people have superpowers!
Autistic people are intelligent!
Autistic people have special skills, talents, etc.! (Yes, autists can be very advanced for their developmental age in a particular area, but usually they have spiky skillsets. This means they might be advanced in one or two areas, but seriously delayed in others.)
Autism isn’t a disability! You’re only disabled by society!
Yes, to some extent, these statements are true for some autists.
But the thing is that autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a disability. If you are not disabled by autism, you do not have ASD.
ASD is included not just in the DSM-5 but also the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11), which is published by the World Health Organization. I mention this because behaviour, traits, etc. associated with clinically diagnosable ASD are not considered normal in any human culture or society around the world. Now or ever. To put it a bit more bluntly: You’re not just disabled by society; you are also disabled by your autism.
If you’re not impaired or limited at all by your particular experience of autism, and if you have a fully independent, fully functional life – in all important life areas – without any support needs at all, then you shouldn’t be diagnosed with ASD.
This is why I love the concept of level 0 autism. You are still autistic, but you are subclinical. Even many professionals don’t know about level 0 autism because it’s not in the DSM-5 (2013) or the DSM-5-TR (2022). It clears up the confusion that I, and many thousands of others, have around autism.
Something becomes a “disorder” when (A) you have enough symptoms that cluster together, and (B) the symptoms are severe enough to cause you and/or others difficulties in important areas of life.
You’re autistic your whole life, but not necessarily to a “disordered” level. I think that’s why there’s confusion. People think “autism” and “autism spectrum disorder” are the same thing.
If you are fully functional and independent but still diagnosed, that trivialises the real impact that autism can have on (realistically and accurately diagnosed) level 2 and level 3 autistics. It also actually hurts the vast majority of (realistically and accurately diagnosed) level 1 autistics.
“Disability” and “disabled” are not dirty words. In my opinion, it’s not necessarily inherently good or bad to be disabled; it’s just a natural part of the human experience. All animal species experience disability, illness, sickness, injury, etc. Erasing those terms from your vocabulary isn’t going to change the struggles that some autistics experience.
I think another reason people say the above catchphrases is because by denying the disabling nature of some autistic traits, they can also gloss over the fact that most autists will have lifelong support needs. Some will never have a fully independent life.
If autistics all just have superpowers, are intelligent, are better than neurotypicals, etc. then society doesn’t need to accommodate for the challenging aspects of their autism. Instead – and especially if you have no co-occurring intellectual disability (ID) or language impairment – you just get labelled with some variation of “crazy” or “difficult personality.”
It is important to fight for the rights and acceptance of autists. But the reality is that some autists would still struggle (e.g., sensory stuff, social and communication stuff, executive dysfunction, and other things) even if we didn’t live in a capitalistic, hostile world.
Focusing on the positives makes everyone feel better. It’s important to celebrate the strengths, talents, capabilities, and beautiful aspects related to many people’s experiences of autism. It is true that with good intervention, support, and accommodations, many autistic people can live happy, healthy, fulfilling lives where they reach their full potential.
But it’s also unfair and unrealistic to gloss over the struggles to the extent that you silence and ignore autists (and their allistic carers) who want to vent about their troubles. Not to mention the autists who view their particular autism as a mostly negative thing they’d rather not have to live with.
High functioning is often still a disability
In many countries outside of the English-speaking Western world, level 1 autism and Asperger’s (where that’s still a diagnosable condition) are considered disabilities.
But elsewhere, toxic positivity has trivialised level 1 so, so much that basically anyone can now self-identify as having ASD without any support needs. People don’t understand the nuance between level 0 and level 1 autism, so they think that to have autism they must have the mildest form which in their mind is level 1 ASD.
When you search online for “autism levels” or read the DSM-5-TR, you only see levels 1, 2, and 3.
In reality, level 1 autism can cause significant challenges. Level 1 autists require support. Even those considered “high functioning” usually still need help!
As just one amusing example as I’m writing this (meta-cognition), I realise that the vast majority of neurotypical people aren’t really interested in deep diving into nuanced discussions about the autistic experience unless they have some kind of personal or professional connection with it.
I realise that all of this writing is coming from an autistic brain and my special interest – which, frankly, I sometimes don’t even want! – is autistic lived experience. Normal people don’t give a shit!
Autistic brains can deeply overthink things (and some autistics care very much about getting it right and not unintentionally offending anyone). Autistic people interested in autism discuss in great detail with each other the intricate nuances between the levels, etc. If there were 1,248 levels of autism (lol!), they would be arguing with each other over the differences between levels 1,247 and 1,248. Some would be worried that they got inaccurately assessed at level 545 instead of 549.
They nitpick over shit that normal people in the real world don’t care about! Ironically, a lot of “autism advocacy” spaces are not really autism-friendly to the vast majority of autists who struggle with aspects of their autism in reality. Let alone friendly to allistic carers.
Here are some of the words, phrases, etc. that are supposedly “controversial,” and you should never use them, even when referring to yourself:
High functioning/low functioning
Mild, moderate, severe, profound autism (I actually like this system because it corresponds to how they categorise intellectual disability)
Asperger’s, Aspie
Disorder, deficits, impairments, symptoms, abnormalities, or any other medical terms (if my autism isn’t a disorder, why was I diagnosed with a disorder? It makes no sense! In some regions, they diagnose with “autism spectrum condition” to soften it a bit though)
Person with autism
Special needs, differently abled, and any other replacement for disabled (trying to destigmatise “disabled”)
Autism puzzle pieces and Light It Up Blue (because they’re associated with Autism Speaks which many autistics believe doesn’t really let autistics speak, ironically. Here is their unintentionally amusing I Am Autism video from 2009.)
Recently, I had two neurotypical people call me “high functioning.” Some autism self-advocates would correct them, telling them the following:
High-functioning denies the struggles and disabling aspects of autism. High functioning implies you’re expected to behave and accomplish things like a neurotypical, or be even better.
Low functioning is used to deny capability, agency, and autonomy.
Yes, it can be true. But was I at all offended or insulted? Did I try to correct them? No! Because I realise that the vast majority of normal people in the real world think in binaries/extremes about autism. Sometimes it can be harmful. But I get what they mean and I’m not offended at all.
I know that psychiatry has moved away from categorical approaches and towards dimensional approaches. In the case of autism – with the DSM-5 (2013), and with the ICD-11 (2019) – they collapsed all the previous categorical diagnoses of autism (autistic disorder, Asperger’s, PDD-NOS, atypical autism, etc.) into ASD.
ASD is basically now the new PDD-NOS (pervasive developmental disorder, not otherwise specified) because it’s so vague, broad, and all-encompassing that it’s almost meaningless.
But human brains conceptualise categories much quicker and easier than dimensions. Now, there’s just autism. So, people interact with you a bit and lump you into “high functioning” or “low functioning.” Usually, they don’t mean offence, but it’s just how brains work: in categories.
Autistic people now discuss what the levels “really mean” because they are the new categories of autism. And we all have our beliefs about what a “level 1,” “level 2,” “level 3” looks like and/or is capable of. So, you’ve got a lot of autists online and their carers arguing about and overthinking this stuff. Ignoring that nuances are everywhere. (Also, I think the split levels were introduced with the DSM-5-TR.)
Asperger’s was once thought of as a condition that can be substantially disabling
If I were diagnosed as a child, I reckon it would’ve been with Asperger’s or maybe PDD-NOS. Unfortunately, a lot of females of a certain generation and older who fit the Asperger’s profile slipped through the cracks over and over again. (The DSM-IV-TR itself says that Asperger’s “occurs much more frequently in males.”) This is largely because Asperger’s females have social mimicry and compensating abilities.
Most people formerly diagnosed with Asperger’s would now fall in the level 0/level 1/lower-end of level 2 range if they were reassessed. What made Asperger’s different:
No co-occurring intellectual or cognitive delay (average or above-average intelligence). I think in the past “high functioning” simply meant that you had no intellectual disability (ID). I’d guess that the majority of autists do have an intellectual disability too (I’m not sure!). With an ID, your autistic traits are much more obvious and you can’t hide or compensate for them as easily.
No significant delay or impairment in language ability (you can speak more or less regularly for your age). They might have unusual prosody: the qualities of spoken language like rhythm, pitch, tempo, accent, stress, etc.
Below are some snippets from the DSM-IV-TR (published in the year 2000) on Asperger’s disorder.
Obviously, a lot of people with Asperger’s (or autism as it’s now known) will disagree with these points and believe they don’t reflect their lived experience, and I 100% respect and understand that. I know very high-functioning autists who have barely any or no support needs at all, and you’d never even register them as autistic.
But, speaking only about my particular experience, I believe these snippets accurately reflect my reality across the decades:
The difficulties cause “considerable disability” (pg. 80).
Usually “the social disability” of people with Asperger’s gets worse over time (pg. 81).
Their interpersonal struggles are “gross and sustained” and are “severe” (pg. 80).
Their struggles must lead to “clinically significant impairment” socially, which obviously can result in “a significant impact” on their ability to be self-sufficient occupationally or otherwise in “important areas” of daily life (pg. 80).
Restricted, perseverative interests are pursued with “great intensity,” meaning they sometimes forget other activities (pg. 80).
People with Asperger’s might have to deal with “victimisation by others” (pg. 82).
Some people with Asperger’s display behaviours “suggesting Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder” (pg. 83).
These words straight from the medical literature – written over two decades ago – describe my lived experiences long, long before I was diagnosed with ASD.
For those who don’t believe the autists who’ve struggled throughout their lives, and think they are just “feeling sorry for themselves” remember that the DSM (“victimisation by others”) was written not by autistic people but by a team of medical professionals. Of course, they’re not gonna say that health practitioners can do that too.
The 2019 ICD-10 entry on pervasive developmental disorders (before ASD was added to the ICD) says: “These qualitative abnormalities are a pervasive feature of the individual’s functioning in all situations.” In all situations.
This is what the 2024 ICD-11 entry for ASD says about compensating (masking):
“Some individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder are capable of functioning adequately by making an exceptional effort to compensate for their symptoms during childhood, adolescence, or adulthood. Such sustained effort, which may be more typical of affected females, can have a deleterious impact on mental health and well-being.”
I think the “exceptional effort to compensate” part needs to be underlined here.
You can’t do it day in and day out for years and be “so high masking,” in all settings, that nobody perceives you as some kind of “weird,” “mentally ill,” “personality disordered,” or “insert negative character trait.” Over the long run, compensating to extreme degrees destroys your mental health. Since childhood, so many people knew there was “something off” about me, but nobody knew it was autism.
And a good assessor familiar with high-compensating autism will know that you are masking. Even with a lifetime’s worth of interpersonal trauma that forced me into becoming (subconsciously) extremely high masking to a paranoid, hypervigilant level whenever I could be perceived by other people, I couldn’t “fail” my autism evaluation because of my masking.
I actually prefer the term “compensating” because it recognises that the differences (or “deficits”) are there in the first place.
Due to accumulated trauma, you learn more ways to compensate for your autism, which makes it exceptionally difficult for clinicians, especially those unfamiliar with autism, to identify your autism.
Many autists have been deeply messed over by the mental health system. I have too. But it can be difficult to identify your autism if it looks like a hundred mental health conditions. And if you’ve learned to hide it.
Various traumas, etc. might mean you do have the other mental health conditions you’re diagnosed with (but not necessarily). And, along with all this, masking itself affects your mental well-being. The DSM-5-TR says that around 70% of autistics have one mental disorder and 40% have two or more.
So, I’m not pissed off at mental health practitioners for missing my autism anymore.
Most autists capable of compensating for their autism will probably choose to do so, consciously or subconsciously. And I don’t believe that even with “exceptional effort” you can 100% hide it for hours on end.
The DSM-5 (2013) says that compensating autists without an ID struggle in new environments where there’s no support, because of the stress from “consciously calculating” all these complex social dynamics that are “intuitive” for neurotypical people (pg. 53). That’s the story of my fucking life!
Once you’ve discovered you’re a high-compensating autist, it’s best to learn how to selectively mask and unmask when it’s safe to do so, rather than kill yourself trying to hide your “abnormalities” all the freaking time. Even when I was immensely high masking, people still thought I was weird! Might as well be open about it.
Surprise, surprise, the medical literature perfectly describes my lived experiences. I have deficits to the neurotypical mind ‘cause the vast majority of humanity (cross-culturally) is neurotypical. I’m not at all offended by any of the medical terms because it’s the truth, speaking only about myself. I am fucking weird and abnormal.
Autistic people are usually honest. This is how I see things.
What does level 3 autism really look like (in real life)?
The viral spread of misinformation about autism on social media is deeply concerning. Maybe “Nothing about us, without us” (a disability-rights slogan) has gone too far. I think it might also be affecting how even well-educated clinicians are diagnosing autism.
Nowadays, we have some instances of people with fully independent and/or even highly successful lives – e.g., with some of the following: thriving careers, high-paying leadership roles, advanced degrees, happy marriages, raising children, owning homes – being late diagnosed in their 20s, 30s, or older with level 3 autism.
So, some people now being diagnosed with level 3 autism as adults are capable of many things that the vast majority of neurotypical, non-disabled people can’t even achieve.
Then you add the lifelong, neurological disability of autism spectrum disorder at any diagnosable level. With level 0, yes, it’s possible to be completely independent and successful. Some level 1s can do many of these things with support. The majority of level 2 adults are a different story. Then there’s level 3 autism.
In reality, level 3 autism is a profoundly disabling, blatantly obvious disability that is apparent to the casual observer when this person is a young child (before age five). They simply cannot “mask” (or compensate for) their struggles to the same degree.
Compared to less severely impacted autistic people (such as myself, and not compared to the general population), these people “require very substantial support” often, but not always, throughout their entire lives.
The key word here is “require.” As in, without this support, they will die – especially as young children who haven’t learned any survival or coping skills – because they cannot take care of their basic survival needs, basic activities of daily living (basic ADLs), independently.
It is paradoxical that someone could (A) survive to adulthood with this required very substantial support and (B) also not have access to sufficient support for anybody – family, community members, teachers, health professionals, etc. (absolutely nobody!) – to realise something was seriously amiss with this child.
That’s why a lot of autistic people, not just myself, are confused as to how genuine level 3 autism could have been missed until adulthood.
The only ways this very young child – raised in any modern human culture – could survive to adulthood without being diagnosed with autism are:
Caregivers refusing to/being unable to get them diagnosed but keeping them alive
Getting diagnosed as a child with another serious and obvious disability
Being raised in a cult or extremely impoverished region, etc.
Serious medical neglect
Level 3 is a spectrum and is not the same as profound autism. Profound autism is pretty much like level 4 autism (co-occurring profound intellectual disability, 24/7 lifetime support, cannot converse even with AAC devices, the most challenging and harmful behaviour). There’s some controversy over profound autism, but I think of it like the most severe form of level 3 (‘cause each level is a spectrum).
People with level 3 autism often:
Cannot complete all the basic/physical ADLs on their own (these are the ADLs that keep their physical body alive, e.g., eating, toileting, dressing themselves, keeping themselves safe. Other autistic people with milder autism – level 1 and 2 – might struggle not with basic ADLs but with instrumental ADLs, stuff like budgeting, shopping, house chores, cooking, planning activities, driving, etc.)
Will never live independently and will require daily support to survive for the rest of their lives (some have said that level 3 autism precludes independent living, but I think it also depends on the early intervention).
Cannot speak or have limited speaking ability (but many can communicate via AAC devices like apps).
Have a significant intellectual disability (not always, but usually).
Have obvious self-harming or challenging behaviours (head hitting, aggressive meltdowns or behaviour, property destruction, dangerous eloping, smearing faeces or eating faeces, incontinence, inability to sleep, etc.) For example, some have to wear helmets, safety harnesses, ear defenders, and adult nappies.
How could this be missed?!
The absurdity of someone with level 3 autism (A) surviving to adulthood, (B) magically accomplishing all this shit that non-disabled people can’t achieve without support, and in our capitalistic, cut-throat world that is deeply hostile to even mildly disabled people, and (C) getting late diagnosed in their 40s with autism spectrum disorder at level 3 makes me laugh!
I’m laughing not out of disrespect for level 3 or their carers – there’s nothing shameful about being disabled – but out of the sheer absurdity that this could be missed and, yet, they still go on to achieve all these things without the required very substantial support in relation to other autistics, such as myself.
Better than any internet person reading this who hasn’t met me in real life, I know myself. And I know what real level 3 is like. I know that this is not reality. I go back and forth in my mind about whether I should publish this piece, but I think I will. “Cause some of us autists gotta speak out about this absurdity.”
(OK, I’m a little bit bitter that I probably could’ve accomplished more in life if I had been identified as a kid and gotten a lot of help that I needed at a young age! I don’t wanna share too much ‘cause I know sometimes autistics can overshare stuff, but let me just say that – as someone with milder autism – as a preteen, people knew I was struggling significantly.)
I’m not saying these things to downplay the capabilities and growth potential of level 3 autistics. It’s true that levels can change. A kid diagnosed at level 3 at a very young age can, with extensive and good support and intervention, improve to level 2 or 1 – especially if there’s no significant ID.
I’m just saying it ‘cause it’s wrong and somewhat offensive that level 3 (or “high support needs” in relation to other autistic people) is being appropriated by and even diagnosed in fully independent and even super-successful adults with absolutely no support needs. That is deeply unfair. I’ve read and heard a lot of stories. And I’ve communicated with lots of autists from six continents.
People interpret words differently. Many haven’t seen a real level 3 autistic in their lives. So, here are some videos featuring people whom I believe would be at level 3 (some could be more like profound autism):
I Only Date Guys Who Accept My Autistic Sister: 27-Year-Old Caregiver
Autism Teen Adam Made A Scene at a Market
Family with adult sons that have autism says there isn’t enough help available
Raising Children With Autism: A Lifetime of Care
Severely autistic boy having a melt down
Living With My Special Needs Daughter Reina
‘I’m Scared of My Own Autistic Child’
Trying to Cope With A Severely Autistic Child
What Is Severe Autism With Self-Injurious Behaviors?
Autism Meltdown at the Mall (maybe level 2)
I think that some of these autistic people in these videos don’t really fully understand what autism is. I find it hard to believe that some of these people really enjoy behaving like this.
(To each their own. Some wheelchair users would love to be able to walk. Others are proud wheelchair users. Some deaf people would take a cure. Others love being Deaf – with a capital D – and the Deaf culture.)
It shouldn’t be taboo to say that Asperger’s (with no co-occurring ID or language impairment) is qualitatively very different from more severely affected autists with an ID. It’s just the reality. Of course, the presence or absence of an intellectual disability makes a huge freaking difference.
Some people previously diagnosed with Asperger’s (or who identify with the term) use it out of respect for more severely affected autistics. By doing so, they’re saying that, yes, they’re autistic, but their struggles are not the same.
I think some of these autistic self-advocates are naïve young people from the social-media generation who think that you can just identify as autistic without even knowing much about it. Regardless of biological reality.
From my current understanding, autism usually has a strong genetic component. (And it’s usually biological females who are the high-compensating autists.) The DSM-5-TR says that studies have estimated the heritability of autism ranges from around 35% to over 90%, based on twin studies.
With good but misinformed intentions, many people are desperately trying to depathologise autism, which can be – but is certainly not always – a seriously disabling condition. Obviously, not for everyone. Many autists don’t see themselves as disabled, and aren’t disabled, and that is 100% valid and understandable.
I don’t “identify” as autistic. I just am autistic. I was born autistic, have lived my whole life with autism, and will be autistic forever.
This will come across as harsh, and some autists will hate me for saying this, but the feelings of the least-impaired autistic people are not as important as the basic survival and support needs of the most-impaired autistic people (and their often-lifelong carers). If you disagree, that’s fine.
How do I think this “identity” issue could be solved? I don’t know. I was going to say that maybe autism without ID could be renamed something else to differentiate us from those with ID who usually have more support needs. But I also know there are level 2 (and even level 3) autists who don’t have an ID. There are also level 1 autists with an ID.
Criticisms/limitations of the social model of disability
I know that the social model of disability doesn’t ignore the inherently disabling traits of your disability. I don’t know the historical background about these topics and, frankly, it doesn’t interest me and I don’t care.
But I imagine that the social model was kinda originally intended for disabilities other than ones like autism, which can look very different between people.
For example, if you have to use a wheelchair and a building doesn’t have an accessibility ramp, then that is a straightforward example of how society disables you. If you are deaf and there are no hearing aids, captions, sign-language interpreters, etc. society has disabled you.
The nature of autism makes it exceptionally challenging if not impossible to completely accommodate for the vastly different and contradictory ways it appears. Autistic traits themselves can be contradictory. Some autists have auditory hypersensitivity and others have auditory hyposensitivity.
People always think in terms of hypersensitivity (of the eight senses, the five most people know about plus proprioception, interoception, and vestibular), but many autists are hyposensitive (to any of these senses). One autistic might seek out and enjoy loud noises, bright lights, busy environments. Even more challenging is that even for just one autistic, their hyper- or hyposensitivities to any of the eight senses can change.
It’s not the same as other disabilities, such as vision or hearing loss, where the disability is more or less the same for everyone but with a scale of severity, so the accommodations are not as complicated.
Add on top of this the fact that most autistic people have co-occurring disabilities, physical/mental health conditions, etc.
Another criticism is this: The most severely disabled people who are sometimes struggling to survive and who require the most help and societal changes are also expected to radically transform every fabric of society, advocate and protest, etc., while barely surviving? Isn’t that sort of illogical and unfair?
I think it’s the rich family members of disabled people who can advocate for and accomplish the best societal changes for disabled people, rather than laying all that responsibility on disabled people, especially marginalised ones.
Another obvious criticism is that while, yes, the social model is extremely idealistic and aspirational, we also have to exist and survive in society as it is – and the world is sometimes fucking hostile to disabled people – not as we wish it were.
Having read stories from around the world, I’m glad that ASD is in the ICD-11. Good.
The autists with no support needs really need to think deeply about what they’re advocating for and whether these approaches are helpful or harmful to the most severely autistic people (and their carers), and even to the lesser-affected autists.
Without ASD as an internationally recognised and diagnosable medical disability… Then what? What will happen is:
States, schools, workplaces, healthcare systems, institutions, etc. around the world won’t provide services, supports, programs, accommodations, etc. for autistic people and their carers. This is especially bad for the more severely affected autists.
Autistic people will not have legal protections against ableism and abuse. Why grant accommodations, increase accessibility, etc. if autism isn’t a disability and is just a superpower? There needs to be some kind of legal repercussions.
No diagnosis means no help. This is why many late-diagnosed autists are frustrated that it took so long for a correct diagnosis. Even with a diagnosis, it’s hard to get help.
The fact that some – well-intentioned but misinformed – least-impaired autists are actively advocating against the things that the most-impaired autists need to survive is horrific, when you really think about this.
Final thoughts
I think autism self-advocates and allistic neurodiversity folk are trying their best not to offend autistic people/people with autism. But, speaking only about myself, I’m not insulted one bit.
It’s because I’m learning how to not take myself so seriously, to give myself so much grace – which I was never given before in my entire life – as I now know I’m living with a lifelong neurological condition that I was born with and didn’t choose to have. I feel bad for the five-year-old Monique, the 15-year-old Monique, etc. who struggled for so long without any framework to understand what was going on besides “mental illness.” (Which opened up a whole new world of trauma, too.)
Of course, non-autistic autism specialists (researchers, clinicians, scientists, etc.) who have spent decades of their lives learning about and researching autism – many of them also involved in scientific research which I will never even begin to understand – and who have (collectively) interacted with thousands of autistics and their carers know far more about autism than I will ever know.
The lived experiences and perspectives of the non-autistic, lifelong carers for autists are very important and necessary too.
Autistic people are only the experts on their particular experience of autism, not on “autism” as it affects every autistic. Remember that autism is mostly a social and communication disorder (social-reciprocity challenges, etc.), so, many of us are not exactly the best at understanding or relating to other people.
Frankly, I believe I have a medical condition called autism spectrum disorder, because I do have a medical condition called autism spectrum disorder. That is the belief framework that makes the most logical sense to me and requires the fewest mental gymnastics of me.
All my lived and living experiences, just how I am qualitatively speaking (perfectly described for decades by the diagnostic manuals), my genetics, my co-occurring physical/mental health problems, etc. point to ASD.
Even if neurodiversity (a socio-political ideology) and the social model of disability (and all the other models of disability) had never existed, I would still be autistic and have a neurodevelopmental disability according to the medical model. There is no society where my autism isn’t a disability. (Lots of us would still struggle even in some hypothetical society only for autistic people.)
Obviously, I disagree with the pathology paradigm in the sense that I don’t believe that autism – the millions of autistic individuals around the world – should be cured, fixed, or treated without consent. However, it’s extremely difficult with young kids at level 3. I know ABA (applied behaviour analysis) has hurt many autistic kids. But I also know it’s helped many autistic kids.
I don’t think “autism” itself, in all its millions of manifestations, needs a cure. But nuance and delicate wording are needed here! Depending on the individual and how autism affects them personally, they might want to be neurotypical.
I see why many autists are very worried when people talk about a cure. They’re concerned that if there were one that it would be forced on all autistic children. I respect and understand proud Autistic people (with a capital A) and their identity and culture. But I also understand the minority of autistics who wish there were a cure for their particular autism only.
Many autists are grieving their autism diagnosis. I think we should hold space for these people.
I also believe more diagnosed autists should be kinda pissed off that these self-identifying adults are waltzing in and claiming any level of ASD – and especially level 3 – as their “identity” whilst both (A) refusing to get this formally validated by an autism specialist and (B) not having any form of disability. If you truly have ASD, you need help. A diagnosis can only help you, not harm you.
And, no, I don’t believe self-identified people should be included in autism-specific research. But that’s what is happening! I recently participated in such a study.
Learning that I’m autistic and disabled has utterly humbled me unlike anything else imaginable. I don’t need to be defensive anymore. I see that these things that I thought my whole life were “character flaws” or “mental illness” were related to my autism (and, especially, my unsupported autism).
Like I said at the beginning, the very last thing I ever intend to do is to cause additional harm to autistics. You can completely disagree with me on everything I’ve written here, and that’s okay! I’m not really trying to convince anyone to change their mind but to just express some thoughts I have.
But, yeah, I also know there are lots of autists out there who are too scared to speak openly and honestly about their challenges or beliefs for fear of being attacked, shamed, or misunderstood. But if you look on Reddit, there are many people discussing their challenges because it’s more anonymous.
I’m really happy for people who love being autistic. I also 100% understand people who’d rather be neurotypical. If you read this entire infodump, I sort of can’t believe it, but thanks!











